Caramel Apples Favors for Events & Weddings

Tuttle’s homemade caramel apple treats are a hit at lots of events in the Indianapolis area.

Tuttle’s famous caramel apples are a favorite every year from Labor Day through Christmas.  Made with fresh apples and hand dipped in caramel topping, they are the favorite addition to any wedding or special event. 

Why Tuttle’s Caramel Apples?

  • Fresh picked apples right from the orchard give them a fresh flavor and crunch.
  • Our famous caramel topping that Tuttle’s customers love.
  • Fresh dipped for your event.
  • Simple appealing packaging that fits with any event theme.
  • Reasonably priced for a top quality product.

Caramel Apple Favor Availability: 

We make fresh caramel apples from Labor Day weekend through Christmas.   Caramel apples are available for pickup at our far east Indianapolis Farm Store location.

Flavors & Styles for Caramel Apple Favors: 

We offer the following toppings:* 

  • Caramel (only available in bulk packaging; not available individually wrapped.)
  • Caramel w/Peanuts:  our most popular.
  • Caramel w/Fall Sprinkles:  available in Sep/Oct.
  • Caramel w/Heath Bar: a delicious, gourmet option. 
  • Caramel w/Custom Sprinkles:  from time to time customers bring us their own color of sprinkles to use that fits with their theme.  This must be arranged with Tuttle’s staff in advance. 

Allergen Note:  all apples are made in a kitchen where peanuts are present.

Caramel Apple Favors Packaging Options:

  • Bulk packaging:  these caramel apples are placed inside a baking cup and stored in boxes of 20-25 apples per box.  They are not individually wrapped.  This is a great option for those who would like to wrap their own apples or when guests will eat them at an event and do not require a “take home” packaging option.  
  • Individually Wrapped:  these caramel apples are placed in a baking cup and then inside a clear plastic bag.  The bag is tied with a kraft raffia bow making it a perfect solution for all types of event themes and colors.  Plain caramel apples are not available individually wrapped.
  • Bulk Caramel Apples (Plan, Peanut, Sprinkles)
  • 200 or More
  • $180each
  • 75-199 Apples
  • $190each
  • 25 to 74 Apples
  • $250each
  • Individually Wrapped Caramel Apples
  • 200 or More
  • $245each
  • 75-199 Apples
  • $255each
  • 25 to 74 Apples
  • $275each
  • Heath Bar Gourmet Apples Bulk Packaging
  • 200 or More
  • $350each
  • 75-199 Apples
  • $375each
  • 25 to 74 Apples
  • $475each
  • Heath Bar Gourmet Apples Individually Wrapped
  • 200 or More
  • $375each
  • 75-199 Apples
  • $395each
  • 25 to 74 Apples
  • $495each
Are your apples available for shipping?
What type of apples do you use?
When do I need to place my order?
Do you deliver?
I am having a Saturday wedding, when should I pick up my apples?
How should I store my caramel apples?
My guests have a peanut allergy, what do you recommend?

Place your Bulk Caramel Apple Order:


Your Name (required)

Phone Number (required)

Your Email (required)

We will contact you to confirm your order before making it. What is your preferred number for contact?

How many and what types caramel apples would you like to order?

Desired Day/Time of Pickup (One week minimum lead time for online orders. Please contact our farm store if you need your order sooner.

Select Preferred Packaging: