Taste the difference of orchard grown produce. From our farm, to your plate.

Cafe Hours

Current Hours:

Monday – Saturday:
9:00am – 6:00pm (meals served from the Cafe Monday- Friday from 10:30am to close)

– Closed Sundays –

Group Reservations

Bringing a group of more than 10 people?

Want to order off the main menu (best for groups of 15 or less)?  No problem, just call ahead and let us know you are coming:  317-326-2278

For groups of 15 or more we offer group menu and/or tour options:  Click here for details.

Relax in our friendly cafe or in outdoor seating to enjoy views of the orchard and greenhouses beyond.

Freshly prepared every day, our food reflects what’s growing at the farm. In the warm spring or summer weather you can sit outside and enjoy a succulent salad. On chillier days in November through August, you can snuggle up in the cafe seating with a comforting soup, a fresh coffee, or a luscious slice of pie.

This is a place to linger over lunch with friends. It’s also an excellent source of inspiration on what to do with all those beautiful veggies…

Made with delicious, orchard fresh ingredients

Our menus may change frequently based upon ingredient availability from our farmers, but will always pleasantly surpass your expectations!

Meet the Chef

Our executive chef, Kelly Kimpton is a lifelong chef who values sustainability and supporting local producers, farmers and artisans.  A graduate from the Culinary Institute of America she has experience in catering, restaurants and spas across the US.  She joined the Tuttle’s team in April of 2017, and has been delighting us with her amazing creations ever since.  

Our Lunches are Farm Fresh!

Tuttle’s cafe offers sandwiches, soups, and other lunch and dinner items that are made with ingredients we grow and sell right in our Farm Store.  We work with local meat producers and artisans to source great ingredients.  Some of the local people we work with are:

  • The Pork Shoppe
  • Miller Poultry
  • Rhim Foods
  • Broad Ripple Chip Company
  • Caprini Creamery
  • Hubbard & Craven Coffee

Current Menu

changes daily due to produce availability & seasonality

Meals served in the Cafe Monday through Saturday

Click here for this week’s cafe menu.

Treats served Mon-Sat in Tuttle’s Cafe

Indy’s famous hand dipped, caramel apples

At Tuttle’s we hand dip over 20,000 caramel apples each year.  We use only the freshest apples…and some super yummy toppings to make some pretty amazing apples.  We have caramel apples available all through the year.

Need Bulk Caramel Apples for an Event or Gifts?

Bulk Caramel Apple Favor Information

Other Stuff We're Famous For

apple cider slush

We’re famous for our slushies!

We use our award winning apple cider to make some pretty famous apple cider slushies!

Visit us in the summer months to try some of our other fruit flavors like peach and strawberry.

Donuts and other Sweet Treats!

In the fall we offer, fresh apple & pumpkin donuts, as well as, treats from other local bakeries and candy shops including:

  • Good’s Candy Shop in Anderson
  • Pumpkin Muffins from Scholars Inn Bakery
  • Cookies from Montessori Baked Goods
  • Cinnamon Bread from Cornerstone Bread Co.